Charlotte Harbor to Ft Myers Fishing Report

By: Robert Lugiewicz

This year has seen Southwest Florida go from drought to an unusually rainy fall. If the long-term forecasts have been correct, we can expect a lot more rain (and more cloudy conditions) than normal this winter. While there will still be plenty of fishing action, the pattern might not be as familiar as we would like. In those conditions, we'll spend more time searching for fish, and artificial lures make that task easier.

Any well-stocked tackle shop will have a huge assortment of lures, and it's easy to get overwhelmed. So let's look at a few proven classics and learn how to fish them effectively.

Johnson Silver Minnow: Spoons are about the simplest lure you can use. Trolled or cast, they flash and shimmer like wounded bait fish, attracting any fish that eats smaller fish.

The Silver Minnow has a single hook, which points upward as the lure is retrieved. It's meant to be reeled at a moderate and steady pace, wobbling from side to side. Crank too fast and it will spin, twisting your line. To guard against this, a ball-bearing snap swivel is a really good idea.

This spoon features a bendable wire weed guard, which sorta kinda works. If you want to fish a spoon around vegetation, Aqua Dream makes one with cable weed guards. It usually stays grass-free, but it's twice the price.

SPRO Bucktail Jig: Real deer hair is the secret to a great bucktail. Nylon is more durable, but hair pulses with the slightest movement or current, giving it a lifelike appearance that nylon can't match.

Jigging a lure means to bounce or twitch it, and this type of retrieve is highly effective with these lures. Think about where your target fish prefers to feed. For example, mackerel is usually hot near the surface or in mid water, while flounder eat near the bottom. Adjust your sink time accordingly.

Light models (1/8 to 1/2 ounce) can be fished around grassflats or oyster bars and in the surf. For deeper water and stronger currents, go heavier. Two to four ounce versions are good around bridge pilings and channel dropoffs.

D.O.A C.A.L Shad: These fish a lot like a bucktail but offer a completely different action. Being snack size at just 3 inches, they are eagerly taken by predators both large and small. These lures are cheap, but you'll also need separate jigheads to rig them onto, generally in sizes from 1/8 to 3/4 of an ounce. To add to their appeal, they can be marinated in Pro-Cure or other liquid scents.

Rat-L-Trap: When there's a bit of a chop or the water is dark, sound is a great fish attractor. Lipless crankbaits like the Rat-L-Trap make a pretty good ruckus, and all you have to do is chuck it out and reel it in.

These lures dive deep — sometimes too deep. If you're scraping the bottom, try holding your rod tip higher. You may also find the treble hooks are a hassle. I use heavy wire cutters to clip off two of the three points, leaving just the lowest one. Fish still get hooked, but it's less likely that I'll get an unwanted piercing.

Jitterbug: Topwater baits are a lot of fun, but "walking the dog" requires mastering another skill. This old favorite has been catching fish for more than 85 years, and the only technique you need is reeling to make it burble back and forth. Vary the speed for maximum effect, and every now and then stop it completely for a few seconds.

Topwaters are most often used in low light (early or late in the day, or under an overcast sky). In water less than about 3 feet deep, they can be used any time because the fish don't have to look up into the sun to find them. For the same reason, they are always a solid choice for pitching under docks.

The hardest part of fishing any topwater is not taking them out of a hungry fish's mouth. When you see that surface strike, you're going to instinctively set the hook. Don't! Fish often miss these lures. Freeze and wait until you feel the tension of the fish, then all you need to do is reel. If you don't feel anything, just start working the bait again. Setting the hook when the strike misses will just yoink the lure away from a fish which is searching for it, and might send that lure and its hooks flying right at your face.

Many anglers prefer natural bait and dislike artificials. It just makes sense to feed a fish something it can actually eat. You might be surprised, but I agree: If you know where the fish are, real food usually catches more.

However, if a search is required, lures hold up much better to repeated casting and are ideal for covering water. Keeping some in your tackle box and knowing when and how to use them can only work to your benefit. The more tools you have available, the more likely you are to have the right one at the right time. Tight lines.

Don't forget to subscribe to be notified when a new video drops: youtube.com/@FishinFranksClub

Previous
Previous

Tampa/St. Petersburg Fishing Report

Next
Next

FWC Lionfish Challenge sets a new standard